Autism, PDA, and the Challenges of Everyday Life: It Ain't Really About the Toothbrush



Image of chocolate flavored toothpaste lying to the left of blue child-sized toothbrush with image of a sloth on the handle

In most neurotypical households, the toothbrush is about teeth. It's part of a morning and evening routine. Kids may need cueing and support to do it, but it's not their crisis of the day. 

In many autistic households, the toothbrush is a source of suffering. Most autistic people have some form of sensory processing disorder, meaning that our sensory systems are under-responsive to some sensory stimuli and over-responsive to others. An over-response results in extreme discomfort, even pain. Some autistic children and adults can't tolerate the sensation of the toothbrush bristles against their gums and teeth. Many can't bear the intense minty flavor and smell of most toothpastes. Some can't handle the slimy foamy texture of the toothpaste itself or the way a pea-sized amount of substance expands in our mouths. And some have poor proprioception and can't quite feel where in their mouths the toothbrush is, making brushing more stressful. Add to this that toothbrushing happens when we're rushing through a morning routine or exhausted right before bed and the task becomes a source of incredible frustration for many autistic children and adults.

Many PDA autistic children and adults face some of these sensory challenges. I had to scour the internet to find a toothpaste with a mild chocolate flavor and a texture that my son could tolerate, for example. But as he entered autistic burnout from years of school-based trauma, his PDA challenges became more pervasive and severe. It became clear that his challenges with toothbrushing were not primarily sensory challenges, because similar patterns of struggle showed up in so many other areas of daily life. 

Traditionally, clinical descriptions of autistic children's struggles almost always center the challenges of the parents or teachers of these kids. That's why the initial term coined to describe my son's autistic profile was Pathological Demand Avoidance, or PDA. PDA is not in the DSM, so it's not an "official" (aka billable to insurance) diagnosis. Understandings of and supports for PDA autistics are much better developed in the UK, New Zealand and Australia than in the United States, although professionals and parents in the U.S. are catching up. The idea behind the label "pathological demand avoidance" is that autistics with a PDA profile have an especially high anxiety profile and employ avoidance behaviors when faced with real or perceived demands. These avoidant behaviors are even more likely when the person is already experiencing stress or distress from sensory, social, cognitive, or physical challenges. Despite some remaining information sources used by ill-informed clinicians, "avoidance behaviors" are not willful choices of children who need more motivation to do something. These are disability-driven challenges. Many PDA autistics are misdiagnosed with ODD-- Oppositional Defiance Disorder. Talk about locating the problem in the child instead of the systems that should be supporting them. Sigh.

Pathological Demand Avoidance and the Toothbrush

From the perspective of "pathological demand avoidance," here's how many people would describe a typical morning with my son Sammy* (pseudonym) and me in the days before I learned more about his inner experience of demands: 

Sammy is finishing breakfast. I say, "Sammy, when you finish your cereal, please brush your teeth while I bring your socks and shoes to the door for school." [I fetch socks and shoes to simplify morning routine and reduce stress.] Sammy doesn't respond. After I ready his socks and shoes, I find Sammy in his bedroom watching YouTube on his tablet. I remind him to brush his teeth. Without looking up, he says firmly, "Not right now."
 
I sigh loudly, realizing that there isn't enough time to battle about teeth now. "Fine, you can brush after school. Come get your socks and shoes on."
 
Sammy closes his tablet and shouts, "I can't go! I can't!" When I hold up his socks and wait, he says, "I can't go! My legs don't work." Sammy sits up and grabs his knees, rocking gently, staring at his blanket. 

From a "pathological demand avoidance" perspective, in this scene Sammy demonstrates avoidant behaviors to brushing his teeth (going to bedroom, watching tablet, refusing reminders) and avoidant behaviors to going to school (staying in bedroom, announcing he can't go, saying his legs don't work). These avoidant behaviors might have something to do with school-related stressors, or the stress of rushing through a morning routine. When I sigh loudly, Sammy's rejection sensitivity--typical in PDAers-- gets triggered. Now he's feeling attacked and rejected.

I did so much research and sought professional advice on typical "autism" support strategies. I created a visual schedule, added more minor choices (like choosing between two jackets), introduced non-verbal communication strategies and sensory play before breakfast when he was willing. I tried using basketball cards (a special interest of his) as rewards for compliance and he always wanted them-- desperately. But none of these adjustments help. Increasing these supports and motivation didn't make any difference. Even inviting his feedback on how we did mornings didn't help. Sammy wouldn't do what Sammy wouldn't do. 

Pervasive Drive for Autonomy, the Nervous System, and the Toothbrush

Many autistic self-advocates with a PDA profile have reclaimed PDA to mean "pervasive drive for autonomy." Some neurodivergent professionals (often with PDA profiles themselves) extend our understanding of PDA to define it as a nervous system disability. They suggest that PDAers require autonomy to feel safe; when they perceive any real or potential threat to autonomy, their nervous system takes their already high anxiety into a state of panic. Behaviors that appear "avoidant" or "aggressive" to the ill-informed are actually attempts to restore autonomy and resolve feelings of panic. In other words, our children go into "fight, flight, freeze, or fawn" mode when they perceive a potential threat to autonomy. It is not about what they won't do. It's about what they can't do. 

Autonomy and the Toothbrush

Let's revisit Sammy and his toothbrush:  

Sammy is finishing breakfast. His preferred breakfast food isn't available today, so he's already experienced a loss of autonomy by eating his sister's favorite cereal instead. I say, "Sammy, when you finish your cereal, please brush your teeth while I bring your socks and shoes to the door for school." [Ugh. Wait wait wait. He's facing three demands in here! Three potential losses of autonomy. She's saying he needs to finish eating, and she just gave him a direct command to brush his teeth -- which has so many demands embedded in it, like going to the bathroom, opening the toothpaste tube, squeezing it onto the brush, and then brushing all of his teeth. Multi-step demands are like rapid-fire attacks on autonomy. And he'll need to do it quickly. First thing in the morning! Too much!]

Sammy doesn't respond. His whole system has escalated into panic, urging him to yell at me, to let her know how unreasonable this is, how stuck he is. He retreats to the bedroom and tries to calm his system by distracting it with YouTube. This is Sammy in flight mode. 

I enter and quietly remind him to brush his teeth. Without looking up, he says firmly, "Not right now." His system responds to the new command by escalating into fight mode and he's trying so hard not to yell.

"That's okay," I say gently. "We can skip brushing this morning. I wonder if you might be ready to put socks on. If you feel like it, I can help or you can do it yourself." I sit on the floor by his bed and relax my shoulders and jaw, slowing my own breathing to calm my nervous system.

Sammy puts down the tablet and lies down, turning his body toward the wall. Angrily, he shouts, "I can't go!" I see that he's in deep distress. Over time, the stiffness in his body melts as I sit quietly nearby. Tearfully, he murmurs, "I want to go, but I can't. I need help. Help me."

I lay down next to Sammy but not touching. "I'm wondering if it might be ok for me to hold you." Sammy shrugs. I take him into my arms and he sinks back into my embrace. "I love you," I whisper. We remain like this in silence for several minutes. Eventually he says, "I want to be alone now." I get permission to kiss him on the forehead and leave the room. 

Mom's PDA Adjustments


Caught up in the morning madness, I started the day in compliance mode. You're in compliance mode any time you think, "I need to get my child to do x, y, and z." Sammy's anxieties are already high on a school morning, so these demands were too much. When I realized what I was doing, I made several PDA-oriented adjustments. By shifting the tone of my voice, I communicated patience and compassion instead of commands. I used indirect declarative language, since direct questions are often experienced as demands by PDAers.
 

I dropped the demand of toothbrushing completely in the hopes that this would be enough for him to recover the spoons needed to go to school. I sat below him, on the floor, to minimize my physical presence over him, increasing his sense of autonomy. I lay down near him without touching as an indication of care but without force or expectation. I avoided eye contact because eye contact is often experienced as a demand for autistic people and feels especially threatening when someone is already in distress. Most importantly, I deliberately invites calm into my body so that I could share that calm with my child.

 Moving Forward

If Sammy experiences this much distress from breakfast, toothbrushing, and shoes in the environment where he is most loved and most supported, imagine how he must experience the stated and tacit demands of a school day. Then, he comes home to dinner and bedtime routines that are filled with more demands when he's already overwhelmed and depleted. PDA is brutal for children who experience it. It's not about the teeth. It's about a need for autonomy and an intense need for connection and acceptance. 

Parenting my PDA child is damn hard. It required completely changing my life and priorities. And the unpredictability of life with a PDAer is so hard on my autistic brain, which relies on predictability to feel safe. So, it's essential that I invest in my own support needs and feelings of safety in any way that I can.

AND the connection that I have with my PDA-autistic child is profound. We have both taken so many risks, testing and learning how to communicate our needs (yes, I also communicate my needs! That's a different post.), how to repair when communication breaks down or we don't have the spoons to show love in the way the other needs. I think the most important thing to start the process was that I always made it clear that I *believed* the experiences he reported to me. If my children say that they can't, then I believe them and try to rally appropriate supports and flexibilities. 

Perhaps the believing is easy for me because I'm also autistic and have pushed through my can't moments so many times in ways that harmed me, leading to fatigue, overwhelm, brain fog and chronic illness. Perhaps it's easier because a combination of therapy and spirituality have helped me to realize that my value as a human being has nothing to do with how productive I am or how much I comply with the expectations of my family, workplace, or society... so I don't worry about my children's productivity or compliance nearly as much as most parents do.

Regardless, the connection that Sammy and I have is unlike anything I've experienced in another relationship. I can't guarantee that level of connection for other parents and their PDA children, but seeing a child feel safe and accepted, seeing the difference in their posture, their demeanor, their sensitivity to the needs of others (when they don't need to be hypervigilant about their own so much)... it feels like witnessing a miracle in action. Because that's what Sammy is. He's a miracle. I get to witness and take part in a miracle every day. And it's my privilege to do so.



 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

I Let My Kid Yell at Me (and why I'm not ashamed): PDA Autism & Family Life

Naming the Spice